Home 
 Ice Cream Cakes 
 Flavors 
 News 
 Newsletters 
 Odds & Ends 
 Contact 
 Guestbook 
 Mailing List 
 Photos 
 Jobs 
 
 Feedback? 
 
Mad Maggie's Ice Cream

The popularity of our various flavors is interesting to watch. I love swapping lists with other ice cream stands in other parts of the country to see how tastes vary across the nation. It's also interesting to see how our flavors change in popularity from year to year. (You can view the 2003 rankings here.)

Here is the final tally of the relative popularities of the flavors we sold in 2004:

Flavor Rankings: 2004
1 Vanilla 10.80
2 Chocolate 8.06
3 Cookie Dough 6.55
4 Chocolate Chip 5.04
5 Black Raspberry 3.89
  Mint Chip 3.89
7 Coffee 3.74
  Oreo 3.74
9 Peanut Butter Cup 3.31
10 Coffee Oreo 3.17
11 Black Raspberry Chip 2.66
  Candy Store Floor 2.66
13 Mad Moose 2.59
14 Strawberry 2.52
15 Peppermint Stick 2.30
16 Massachusetts Mud 2.09
17 Kahlua Brownie 2.02
18 Coffee Chip 1.87
  M&M 1.87
20 Vanilla Caramel 1.80
21 Choc PB Cup 1.73
22 Heath Bar 1.66
23 Bubble Gum 1.58
24 Almond Joy 1.44
  Ultimate Chocolate 1.44
26 Coconut Fudge 1.30
27 Butter Pecan 1.22
28 Lemon Nerds 1.01
  Maple Walnut 1.01
30 Black Walnut 0.86
  Cake Batter 0.86
  Pistachio 0.86
33 Mint Cookie 0.72
  Orange Sherbet 0.72
35 Low Carb 0.65
36 Fresh Strawberry 0.58
  Grapenuts 0.58
  Mango Sherbet 0.58
39 Snickers 0.50
40 Cappuccino Espresso 0.43
  Cherry Vanilla 0.43
  Chocolate Hazelnut 0.43
  Orange Pineapple 0.43
44 Fresh Blueberry 0.36
45 Dulce de Leche 0.29
  Red Raspberry 0.29
  Strawberry Cheesecake 0.29
  Sundae Special 0.29
49 Peach 0.22
50 Apple Pie 0.14
  Banana Crunch 0.14
  Blk Raspberry Sherbet 0.14
  Blueberry Sorbet 0.14
  Brownie Batter 0.14
  Cantaloupe 0.14
  Ginger 0.14
  Guinness 0.14
  Kahlua Chip 0.14
  Kris Krunch 0.14
  Lemon Sherbet 0.14
  Low Carb Lemon 0.14
  Mango 0.14
  Orange Chip 0.14
  Red Raspberry Sorbet 0.14
  Reverse Chip 0.14
66 Blackberry Sorbet 0.07
  Chocolate Marshmallow 0.07
  Chocolate Sorbet 0.07
  Coffee & Donuts 0.07
  Coffee Brickle 0.07

A few thoughts on the rankings:

  • Vanilla and Chocolate are so popular because they're used in so many of the sundaes and frappes that we make.
  • Several of the flavors (e.g., Cake Batter, Strawberry Cheesecake, Apple Pie) might have ended up higher on the list if we had offered them as part of our regular lineup from the start. Like last year, now that we've seen how popular they are, you can bet we'll keep them in stock in 2005!
  • A bunch of the lower ranked flavors were done as tests as part of our "flavor of the week" offerings.